
I just finished reading this book. The book is about the 1979 extremist take over of the Grand Msoque in Mecca It is pretty good although there are some mistakes that someone not that familiar with Islam might not catch. For example, at one point the author mentions that men not wearing gold or silk is a sign of extremism, this despite the fact that it is a well known prohibition followed by all practising Muslim men, extremist or not.
Some would contend with things treated as facts by this book. The author contends that no Western troops took part in the combat in Mecca whereas others, including those in my wife's family from Mecca, contend Western troops did see combat in the Grand Mosque in Mecca.
Also of interest, I was unaware of the fact that two African Americans took part in the Sunni extremist take over the mosque. I had never heard of that before. One was killed in the fighting and the other was captured and later released by Saudi authorities. In his case the American passport kept him from loosing his head like the vast majority of the others did.
Sunday, March 16, 2008
Labels:
Extremism,
Saudi Arabia
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

5 comments:
Salaams Brother:
I'm not surprised that some see not wearing gold or silk as signs of extremeism.
Some people think hijabs and niqabs are extreme, even in some "Muslim" countries. Also, some see beards in the same way.
I've seen the book and read the cover blurbs, but haven't bought it. What do you recommend? Buy now, wait till the paperback, or go to the library?
I remember hearing about this event when it happened. The book sounds like it would be an interesting read. Thanks for bringing it to our attention!
As salaamu 'alaykum Abu Sinan,
You beat me to it, bro.
I have a draft of a review of the book waiting to go on my blog, but I still have a few chapters left to go in the book.
I have seen Trofimov doing a few interviews as well. I admire his reporting and he does a pretty good job of understanding different nuances.
I wish we would see more Muslims (who may be able to capture the nuances better)writing semi-scholarly popular works in English in general. Of course, it is probably even harder for a Muslim not to be biased than a non-Muslim (although the Muslim understands all the different nuances, he/she will often selectively discuss things in a way to advance his or her own agenda).
Salaam.
Jdsg,
I would probably wait until it hits paperback. It is worth the buy, however.
It was interesting to read things about the Kabbah and the Grand Mosque that I wasnt aware of.
Knowing how close the Saudi regime was to folding was intersting as well.
It is an important piece of modern Islamic history.
Abu Noor,
I'll be looking forward to your review, mine was pretty short and just focused on a couple of interesting points.
Post a Comment